Cookout Milkshake Flavors 2026: Full List, Prices and Calories
Cookout milkshakes cost $3.99 each in 2026, and the menu lists more than 40 flavors. That price was the same at every store we checked, from Tampa, Florida to Myrtle Beach, South Carolina. Below you will find all Cookout milkshake flavors, the Cookout milkshake prices by store, and the calories and sugar for each one from the official Cook Out nutrition guide. Shakes are also part of the Cookout tray, so you can add one to a full meal.
Jump to: How Much Are Milkshakes? All Milkshake Flavors Milkshake Calories Lightest and Heaviest Seasonal Flavors Most Popular Shakes Mixing Flavors Shake in a Tray Milkshakes vs Floats

How Much Are Cookout Milkshakes?
A regular Cookout shake costs $3.99, and you can add one to a tray instead of the drink for $1.50 more. The price is printed in the top corner of the blue “Creamery” menu board, next to the calorie range of 510 to 900. We read the same $3.99 price on three stores’ boards between 2024 and 2026.
| Store | Photo date | Fancy Milkshake | Shake in a tray |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tampa, FL | Oct 2026 | $3.99 | +$1.50 |
| Myrtle Beach, SC | Aug 2025 | $3.99 | not shown |
| Greensboro, NC | Dec 2024 | $3.99 | not shown |
Cook Out sells one main size, called a regular shake on the tray board. There is no small or large shake on the boards we checked. Tax is added at the window.
All Cookout Milkshake Flavors
The official Cook Out nutrition guide lists 44 shake flavors, and the menu boards add a few seasonal ones. We grouped them so they are easier to scan. Flavors marked with a month only appear in that season.
- Classic: Vanilla, Hershey’s Chocolate, Strawberry, Cherry, Red Cherry, Peach, Pineapple, Caramel, Fudge, Mint, Malted Milk, Chocolate Malt, Cappuccino, Mocha, Walnut
- Banana: Fresh Banana, Banana Berry, Banana Blueberry, Banana Cherry, Banana Fudge, Banana Nut, Banana Pineapple, Banana Pudding, Peanut Butter Banana
- Chocolate and nut: Double Chocolate, Chocolate Cherry, Chocolate Nut, Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Chip Mint, Caramel Fudge, Peanut Butter, Peanut Butter Fudge
- Candy and cookie: Reese’s Cup, Oreo, Oreo Mint, Oreo Peanut Butter, M&M, Snickers, Heath Toffee, Butterfinger, Nilla Wafers, Orange Push-Up, Hi-C Punch
- Cheesecake and pie: Philadelphia Cheesecake, Cherry Cheesecake, Strawberry Cheesecake, Blueberry Cheesecake, Caramel Cheesecake, Chocolate Chip Cheesecake, Peach Cobbler, Cherry Cobbler
- Seasonal: Fresh Watermelon (July and August), Peppermint Chip (December), Fresh Eggnog (December)
Not every store carries every flavor every day. If your favorite is missing from the board, ask at the window, because some stores still make it.
Cookout Milkshake Calories for Every Flavor
Cookout milkshakes range from 510 to 900 calories, with Fresh Banana the lightest and Cherry Cheesecake the heaviest. Most fruit shakes land between 540 and 620 calories, while candy, nut and cheesecake shakes run 750 to 925. The table is sorted from lowest to highest calories, using the official Cook Out Nutrition PDF.
| Flavor | Calories | Total fat (g) | Sugar (g) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fresh Banana | 538 | 16 | 80 |
| Peach | 547 | 17 | 86 |
| Vanilla | 555 | 18 | 83 |
| Cappuccino | 555 | 18 | 83 |
| Caramel | 560 | 17 | 87 |
| Banana Pineapple | 566 | 16 | 86 |
| Pineapple | 575 | 17 | 91 |
| Hi-C Punch | 598 | 17 | 99 |
| Red Cherry | 600 | 17 | 96 |
| Mint | 605 | 18 | 96 |
| Malted Milk | 606 | 19 | 89 |
| Strawberry | 610 | 17 | 99 |
| Blueberry | 617 | 17 | 101 |
| Hershey’s Chocolate | 620 | 18 | 103 |
| Mocha | 620 | 18 | 103 |
| Orange Push Up | 638 | 18 | 106 |
| Fresh Watermelon | 645 | not listed | 84 |
| Double Chocolate | 651 | 17 | 118 |
| Chocolate Cherry | 665 | 17 | 116 |
| Banana Berry | 671 | 16 | 111 |
| Chocolate Malt | 671 | 19 | 109 |
| Caramel Fudge | 677 | 21 | 102 |
| Heath Toffee | 701 | 28 | 98 |
| Banana Nut | 704 | 27 | 92 |
| Snickers | 720 | 27 | 100 |
| Chocolate Nut | 752 | 28 | 110 |
| Fudge | 754 | 25 | 109 |
| M&M | 755 | 27 | 107 |
| Nilla Wafers | 763 | 27 | 97 |
| Peanut Butter Fudge | 765 | 34 | not listed |
| Banana Fudge | 772 | 24 | 111 |
| Banana Pudding | 781 | 26 | 99 |
| Chocolate Chip | 783 | 32 | 103 |
| Peach Cobbler | 790 | 27 | 105 |
| Oreo | 802 | 29 | 103 |
| Chocolate Chip Mint | 834 | 32 | 115 |
| Cherry Cobbler | 842 | 27 | 115 |
| Philadelphia Cheesecake | 845 | 42 | 97 |
| Fresh Peanut Butter | 847 | 45 | 83 |
| Walnut | 853 | 40 | 103 |
| Oreo Mint | 853 | 29 | 115 |
| Peanut Butter Banana | 864 | 43 | 85 |
| Reese’s Cup | 894 | 37 | 115 |
| Cherry Cheesecake | 925 | 42 | 115 |

Fresh Banana
$3.99 538 Cal

Peach
$3.99 547 Cal

Vanilla
$3.99 555 Cal

Cappuccino
$3.99 555 Cal

Caramel
$3.99 560 Cal

Banana Pineapple
$3.99 566 Cal

Pineapple
$3.99 575 Cal

Hi-C Punch
$3.99 598 Cal

Red Cherry
$3.99 600 Cal

Mint
$3.99 605 Cal

Malted Milk
$3.99 606 Cal

Strawberry
$3.99 610 Cal

Blueberry
$3.99 617 Cal

Hershey’s Chocolate
$3.99 620 Cal

Mocha
$3.99 620 Cal

Orange Push Up
$3.99 638 Cal

Fresh Watermelon
$3.99 645 Cal

Double Chocolate
$3.99 651 Cal

Chocolate Cherry
$3.99 665 Cal

Banana Berry
$3.99 671 Cal

Chocolate Malt
$3.99 671 Cal

Caramel Fudge
$3.99 677 Cal

Heath Toffee
$3.99 701 Cal

Banana Nut
$3.99 704 Cal

Snickers
$3.99 720 Cal

Chocolate Nut
$3.99 752 Cal

Fudge
$3.99 754 Cal

M&M
$3.99 755 Cal

Nilla Wafers
$3.99 763 Cal

Peanut Butter Fudge
$3.99 765 Cal

Banana Fudge
$3.99 772 Cal

Banana Pudding
$3.99 781 Cal

Chocolate Chip
$3.99 783 Cal

Peach Cobbler
$3.99 790 Cal

Oreo
$3.99 802 Cal

Chocolate Chip Mint
$3.99 834 Cal

Cherry Cobbler
$3.99 842 Cal

Philadelphia Cheesecake
$3.99 845 Cal

Fresh Peanut Butter
$3.99 847 Cal

Walnut
$3.99 853 Cal

Oreo Mint
$3.99 853 Cal

Peanut Butter Banana
$3.99 864 Cal

Reese’s Cup
$3.99 894 Cal

Cherry Cheesecake
$3.99 925 Cal
Source: official Cook Out Nutrition PDF. Some flavors on the boards (Butterfinger, Banana Blueberry, the newer cheesecake flavors, Peppermint Chip, Fresh Eggnog) are not in the PDF yet, so their calories are not listed.
Every shake has at least 80 grams of sugar, which is more than most adults should have in a full day. If you want a shake with a meal, the fruit flavors keep the total lower. See all Cook Out calories on our Cook Out nutrition page.
Lowest and Highest Calorie Cookout Shakes
If you want the lightest Cookout shake, pick Fresh Banana (538 calories), Peach (547) or Vanilla (555). These three have about 16 to 18 grams of fat and the lowest sugar on the list. The heaviest shakes are Cherry Cheesecake (925), Reese’s Cup (894) and Peanut Butter Banana (864), and peanut butter or cheesecake almost always pushes a shake past 840 calories.
| Lightest shakes | Calories | Heaviest shakes | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fresh Banana | 538 | Cherry Cheesecake | 925 |
| Peach | 547 | Reese’s Cup | 894 |
| Vanilla | 555 | Peanut Butter Banana | 864 |
Seasonal Cookout Milkshake Flavors
Three Cookout milkshake flavors only show up part of the year. Fresh Watermelon is on the board in July and August, and both Peppermint Chip and Fresh Eggnog arrive in December. Because they come and go, check the board when you visit in those months.
| Seasonal flavor | When | Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Fresh Watermelon | July and August | 645 |
| Peppermint Chip | December | not in the PDF |
| Fresh Eggnog | December | not in the PDF |
We update this page when a seasonal flavor appears on a menu board. If you visit in the fall, ask your store if any limited flavor is on the menu that week.
Most Popular Cookout Milkshake Flavors
Banana Pudding is the most searched Cookout shake, with about 590 searches a month in the US. It has 781 calories and 99 grams of sugar. Peach Cobbler, Reese’s Cup and the cheesecake shakes are other rich picks, each above 780 calories, and they are on our best Cook Out order list.
- Banana Pudding: 781 calories, the most searched flavor
- Peach Cobbler: 790 calories, a Southern dessert in a cup
- Reese’s Cup: 894 calories, chocolate and peanut butter
- Cherry Cheesecake: 925 calories, the richest shake on the menu
- Fresh Watermelon: 645 calories, summer only
Can You Mix Cookout Milkshake Flavors?
Some customers ask for two flavors in one cup, and the menu already sells built-in mixes like Banana Berry, Peanut Butter Banana and Chocolate Cherry. Whether your store will blend a custom mix is up to the staff on shift. Ask at the window before you pay. We keep more ideas on our Cook Out secret menu page.
How to Add a Shake to a Cookout Tray
When you order a tray, say the drink you want is a shake and name the flavor. The tray board lists it as “or sub a regular shake,” and the Tampa store charged $1.50 more in October 2026. That makes a tray with a shake about $10.49 at that store, still less than buying a burger, two sides and a shake on their own.
Cookout Milkshakes vs Floats
If you want something lighter than a shake, a Coke float or Cheerwine float has about 380 calories and costs $2.49 at the Tampa store. A float is soda with vanilla soft serve on top, and it counts as the free tray drink. Shakes are thicker and richer, with 510 to 900 calories. See both on our Cook Out desserts page.
Cookout Milkshake Flavors FAQs
How much is a Cookout milkshake?
A Cookout milkshake costs $3.99 in 2026 at the stores we checked in Florida, South Carolina and North Carolina. Adding a shake to a tray instead of the drink costs $1.50 more. Tax is added at the window.
How many milkshake flavors does Cook Out have?
Cook Out has more than 40 milkshake flavors. The official nutrition guide lists 44, and the menu boards add seasonal flavors like Fresh Watermelon, Peppermint Chip and Fresh Eggnog.
What is the best Cookout milkshake?
Banana Pudding is the most searched Cookout shake. Other rich picks are Peach Cobbler and Reese’s Cup. If you want fewer calories, Fresh Banana and Peach are the lightest at 538 and 547 calories.
How many calories are in a Cookout milkshake?
Cookout milkshakes have 510 to 900 calories, depending on the flavor. The menu board rounds this to 510 to 900 calories. Every shake has at least 80 grams of sugar.
Does Cook Out have a small milkshake?
The boards we checked list one regular shake size for $3.99. There was no small or large shake on any of them.
Final Word on Cookout Milkshake Flavors
Cookout milkshakes cost $3.99 at every store we checked, and the board lists more than 40 flavors. Calories run from 538 for Fresh Banana to 925 for Cherry Cheesecake, and most fruit shakes land between 540 and 620. Candy, nut and cheesecake flavors are the heaviest. You can also add any shake to a tray in place of the drink.
Sources: official Cook Out Nutrition PDF; cookout.com/menu flavor list; menu-board photos in Tampa FL (Oct 2026), Myrtle Beach SC (Aug 2025), Greensboro NC (Dec 2024).
